Welcome to Tony D's
At Tony D's, located in Caldwell, NJ, pizza isn’t just food; it’s a passion. Specializing in old-fashioned and Roman-style pies, Tony D's offers a simple yet satisfying menu that highlights the essence of quality ingredients. From the savory Drunken Grandma to the cheesy delight of their thin-crust Margherita, each bite whispers tradition and taste. With a commitment to consistent quality and quick delivery, this cozy spot has garnered a loyal following. It’s perfect for families, casual gatherings, or a quick takeaway. Whether you prefer classic flavors or bold twists, Tony D's ensures a delightful pizza experience that leaves you yearning for more.
Tony D's: Reviews & Ratings
The pizza always good and consistent. Our favs are the chicken bacon ranch and drunken grandma!
We have been ordering from Tony D's for the last three years. They are definitely a Pizza Player. Just understand it is pickup only or delivery not seating available!!!
Yummy pizza. Came as a recommendation to try the square pies. So why not, went for the Drunken Grandma. So good. Very simple menu, which is great so i don't go crazy because we were super hungry. Delivered in 20 minutes and it was still hot. Will be back again for sure
This one has a split review in the family. I love the square pizza and the small pepperoni slices on the pizza. It's got a Roman style to it so be prepared when you go in. A very small spot so ideal for takeout.
The best thin crust pizza around...the Napolitano pizza is absolutely delicious every time. A++++ all the way! Thanks, Tony D
Best pizza you'll ever eat!! Homemade sauce is delicious. Order ahead because since they are so amazing, they can get busy. Yum!
Their pizza is terrific, and unusual - square crusts!? My wife had the gluten free which is the best we've tasted, ever. There was a small error in our order which I will put down to the fact that it was the superbowl and the place was hopping. Veggie Pizza was great with the truffle oil touch and the pepperoni was thick cut and flavorful. Will definitely order again.
It's been about a year since we had our last pizza from Tony D's, and more than three years since I posted my last review. Happily, very little has changed. That is to say, they continue to offer some of the best pizza you'll find in the northern NJ. We once again ordered the Drunken Grandma, which is a square, thin crust pie made with vodka sauce, grape tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil and grated parmigiano. We all agreed it was as delicious as we remembered it to be. It's not a cheap pizza, and it's not the largest square pie, ringing in at $25, but it's worth the price. They describe their pizza as "artisanal" which is a term that usually makes me cringe, but in this case it applies. The quality of the ingredients and the care that go into each pizza is really a cut above what you'll find at most pizzerias. Seriously, when was the last time you encountered hand-cut cherry tomatoes as a topping? It's worth mentioning that Tony D's remains a strictly take-out establishment, and parking can be challenging if you come at a busy time. Fortunately, the service is excellent, and your food will be ready at the time they quote. There is very little on the menu beside pizza other than a few salads and simple appetizer offerings. One non-pizza standout I've had several times is their Buffalo Wings ($12), which is made with their own homemade buffalo-ish sauce that I really like. There aren't many restaurants I review that retain 5-stars through three updates over eight years, but Tony D's is one of them, and it's well deserved.
Simply the best pizza in the Caldwell, Fairfield area. There are a couple of close seconds. But Tony D's gets the nod for sure. One of the main reasons is that essentially all they do is pizza. No sandwiches. No entrees. A couple basic apps and that's it. It's a destination pizzeria worth traveling to but I am fortunate to live just 2 miles away. FYI - No dine in. Take out only.
Location
-
3 Hanford Pl, Caldwell, NJ 07006 Hotline: (973) 228-9500
Welcome to the mouthwatering world of Tony D's, a pizza haven located at 3 Hanford Place in Caldwell, NJ. This delightful establishment prides itself on delivering exceptional pizza with a focus on quality ingredients and artisanal techniques. With a casual atmosphere and friendly service, Tony D’s is perfect for a quick bite or a family meal.
At Tony D’s, the menu is refreshingly straightforward, allowing you to focus on what truly matters—delicious pizza. Their signature offerings like the Drunken Grandma and the classic thin-crust options have garnered rave reviews from excited patrons. For a savory start, try their Buffalo Wings, delicately tossed in homemade wing sauce, or the crunchy Mozzarella Sticks that promise to be an instant hit.
The salads are equally enticing, with the Andrea Salad featuring candied walnuts and Parmigiano cheese, bringing a delightful crunch that pairs well with the suggested balsamic vinaigrette. If you’re seeking something hearty, their pizzas—ranging from a simple Cheese Pizza to one with your choice of toppings—satisfy every craving.
- Vegan and Vegetarian Options: Tony D's understands the evolving palate and caters to diverse dietary needs, ensuring there's something for everyone.
- Convenient Features: Whether you prefer delivery, takeout, or even making a reservation, Tony D's has your dining experience covered. Wheelchair accessibility and outdoor seating options add to the welcoming environment.
- Kid-Friendly Atmosphere: Families can enjoy a meal together here, thanks to a casual vibe and menu items that even picky eaters will love.
- Happy Hour Specials: Don’t miss the chance to unwind with a drink and enjoy a slice at New Jersey's favorite pizza spot.
For those who value a tasty yet no-fuss dining experience, Tony D's pizza offers a pleasant escape from the ordinary. With Yelp-like favorites and a reputation for consistent quality, it’s no wonder that customers keep returning for more. If you find yourself in Caldwell, don’t pass up the opportunity to indulge your cravings at Tony D's.
Feel free to visit them at 3 Hanford Pl, Caldwell, NJ 07006, or give them a call at (973) 228-9500 to place your order. Dive into the deliciousness of Tony D's, where every slice tells a story of flavor and tradition.
